Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

New Barrier to Class Actions for Franchisors



New barriers stand in the way of consumer class-action lawsuits, according to Bethany Appleby of Wiggin and Dana.

This fall the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issued two opinions reversing district court certification of consumer classes. In both instances, the plaintiffs did not present “a viable way of demonstrating” that each proposed class member had actually purchased the product at issue, the court said.

Along with a 2012 Third Circuit decision, these two decisions “present a new barrier for money damage class claims” related to a product purchase, Appleby notes. 

Because many franchise systems involve sales where no record of the purchase is kept,  “these cases are likely to be particularly useful to franchisors defending against consumer class actions,” she adds.

In Marcus v. BMW North America, plaintiffs sued BMW and Bridgestone for selling allegedly defective tires. The court found the class definition in the case raised “serious ascertainability” issues, because the purchase and lease records did not document the brand of tires on each car, and not all owners and lessees had their vehicles repaired at a BMW dealership.

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Add your comment:
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Covers everything from good news to bad judgment

About This Blog

The latest news, opinions and commentary on what's happening in the franchise arena that could affect your business.

Tom KaiserTom Kaiser is senior editor of Franchise Times. He can be reached at 612.767.3209, or send story ideas to tkaiser@franchisetimes.com.
Beth EwenBeth Ewen is editor-in-chief of Franchise Times. She can be reached at 612.767.3212, or send story ideas to bewen@franchisetimes.com.
Nicholas UptonNicholas Upton is restaurants editor at Franchise Times. He can be reached at 612.767.3226, or send story ideas to nupton@franchisetimes.com.
Laura MichaelsLaura Michaels is managing editor of Franchise Times. She can be reached at 612.767.3210, or send story ideas to lmichaels@franchisetimes.com.
Mary Jo LarsonMary Jo Larson is the publisher of Franchise Times Magazine and the Restaurant Finance Monitor.  You can find her on Twitter at




Atom Feed Subscribe to the Franchise Times News Feed »

Recent Posts